2016年10月10日月曜日

Background of Shin-Godzilla Chapter 4 : Japan-U.S. Security Arrangements

 In the movie "Shin-Godzilla" it's Nichibei Ampo (Japan-U.S. Security Arrangements) which is the legal basis for request of support to the American army, so I'd like to talk about it as trivia.
 Right from the start, why American army stay in Japan now ? I believe it's a little known fact that it's the marine force stationed in Japan which is good at landing operation.  
 So if you ask the question to specialists of Japan-U.S. relations, I guess other half answer it's to invade Japan when Japan spur militarism again, and another half answer it's for Japanese but not
to fight with invader to Japan, but to invade Korean Peninsula and stop communists at there.
 (Therefore I think Donald Trump is fuckin liar but clever businessman because he may understand because of the end of cold war, demand of US military in Japan has relatively decreased for America so he might think he can squeeze more money.)
  
 I don't mean to say American army has no deterrent power, but it is said that Japan-U.S. Security Arrangements has a fatal loophole so I believe American won't help Japanese when china invade Japan despite of claim of Trump.
 In facts if you see the articles of Japan-U.S. Security Arrangements, you'll find there is no words "use of force" or "defense obligation" (I think this fuzziness is intentional because article 5 of North
Atlantic Treaty definitely says "forthwith" the parties do necessary "including the use of armed force"!)
 In article 9 it declares that the parties "would act to meet the common danger in accordance with its constitutional provisions and processes". So this treaty only guarantee America submit the action to
the Congress for approval, no more and no less. Needless to say if the American Congress were to vote down, Japan would have no future...
 It's a sad but true democracies do war only when people are fascinated with sense of justice and it has a actual advantage for politicians. Iraq has both of them, but Senkaku islands has neither of them.
 Is Japan a important alliance partner for America ? or just a client country ? I believe many of American people might think "WTF? why we must die for the far east island where no one live?" and many of American politicians might be reluctant to alienate China whose GDP overtake Japanese now.

 U.S.-Japan alliance also has so many demerits for Japan. At okinawa islands helicopters make a flights over the residential area everyday (but they keep out from the area where American live because it's a loud and dangerous !). And when marine rape girls Japanese can't bring them into custody if they escape to the military base because it has extraterritorial right !
 (Recently in some cases American army turn suspects over to the Japanese police before indictment by "sympathetic consideration", but it's also true American governments keep a negative attitude to update the U.S-Japan Status of Forces Agreement)
 Though for the moment many of Japanese have a favorable view of America and not really want militarism. But if Japanese were to learn U.S.-Japan alliance is just a fictitious bill and loyalty to America for 70 years is completely meaningless, I can't deny the possibility that a radical right regime would be born in Japan which insist on nuclear armament and independence from America...
 In the next last chapter, I'd like to talk about relation between the movie and atomic weapon.

2016年10月3日月曜日

Background of Shin-Godzilla Chapter 3 : About Japanese army


 In this chapter I'd like to have a run-through of post-war history of Japan. I think it's boring story for you so I try to put it briefly as mush as possible...
 As you likely know, Japan is a defeated country of World War 2. After Japan accepted the surrender of the Allies in 1945, America-centered occupation forces came to Japan.
 Needless to say the purpose of the forces at the time is to prevent Japanese from war again. 
 So it's the Japanese Constitution which was made by Japanese government under the influence of chief commander Douglas MacArthur in 1947.
 In article 9 the constitution said Japanese people renounce war and never maintain forces forever. This is what we call "Pacifist constitution" which is controversial even now.
 In 1950 Korean War has begun. Many of occupation forces went to Korean Peninsula and the purpose of them at the time was to maintain public order of Japan and make it seawall against the communist country
 So Keisatsu Yobitai(National Police Reserve), which become the predecessor of the Japan Self-Defense Forces, was made for the purpose of complementing Police.
 In 1952 Japan won back it's sovereignty by San Francisco Peace Treaty, Occupation forces stopped making an entry but American forces were still there by Japan-U.S. Security Arrangements.
 And 2 years after Jieitai(Japan Self-Defense Forces) of now was born and purpose of the force became to defend Japan from direct or indirect invasion.
 After that Guidelines for Japan-U.S. Defense Cooperation has been constantly modified and now Jieitai play a role in logistic support of Amerian forces (in this regard Trump tell a lie again !).

 Sorry for boring stentence. I think there are 2 key point.
 Firstly, I don't mean to say Japan has no merit of U.S.-Japan relations but it's also true Japan has been always swayed by national profit of America.
 (After Iraq war has begun in 2003, Japanese politicians were horrified because Deputy state secretary Armitage pressured Japanese government to send troops despite of article 9. Now Shinzo Abe build a stable administration and it seems that condition for constitutional change is right, but the irony is that now chinese GDP overtake Japanese and role of Armitage is to give him a warning "Don't provoke China casually !")
 Secondly, from the standpoint of the law Japan normally can's maitain any bullets and guns. It's a argumentative and complicated legal interpretation issue but it is said that Japan is permitted to have
minimum weapons for self-defense in the constitution, nevertheless it's also true Japan has so many legal and social restrictions for usage of the force. 

 I heard that the scene of "Shin-Godzilla" got a bad name at oversea where prime minister stop attacking because of delay in escape of people. I’d appreciate it if you keep in mind supposedly Jieitai is not 'Army' but 'Self defence force' so even if it were to produce just a one casualty left-leaning party and media, who are allergy to military and believe not American forces but Pacifist constitution keep Japan from war for 70 years, must heavily criticize the government's actions.
 It has no direct relation with the movie but in the next chapter I'm expected to write about American force in Japan.